“For me it was just a haircut and started out about me
being women. Now we’re talking about religion versus gender versus human rights
and business in Ontario.” said McGregor.
So I was looking through the
newspaper to find some interesting story to share for this week’s blog post
when I came across this article. Here is a very brief summary: A woman named
Faith McGregor wanted to get a haircut, she walks into a Barber shop on Bay St.
She asks the Barber to cut her hair, but the barber denies her request due to
his religion. This Barbershop does not do haircuts for Women, mainly because of
their religion. As Co-Owner Omar Mahrouk states “in his Muslim faith, he is
prohibited to touch a women who is not related to him.” As a customer McGregor was insulted she felt
like a “second class citizen” so she filed a complaint with the human right
tribunal of Ontario. So far this case didn’t seem like a big issue in the court
room, currently they are thinking of a negotiation. We have to look at this
article at two different viewpoints. In the customer’s point of view she should
have the right to cut her hair anywhere she wants in Canada, it is a free
country. However did she have to make it a big issue if that wasn’t the case?
In the case of the Barber he was Muslim, though should he be mixing his
religious values with his business practices? He is losing customers, which
could affect his business. Here is a video:
http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/story/2012/11/15/toronto-haircut-mcgregor.html
In my opinion it is not a good idea to mix religion and
business especially in a society which consist of a diverse population. Once again
it depends where you plan to conduct the business; you must obtain knowledge of
your surroundings before making or selling any products.
So what do guys think?
I actually got this article from the Toronto Star
Newspaper but here is another link, in case anyone wants to read in depth about
the article
(I doubt it:)
http://ca.news.yahoo.com/blogs/dailybrew/human-rights-collide-woman-files-complaint-against-muslim-170208719.html
One of the more interesting, unique posts Hima!
ReplyDeleteUnfortunately, as we saw a chapter or two ago, religion and business inevitable must mix as religion plays a very large part of many cultures.
That being said, here's my two cents on the barber issue specifically.
I 100% agree that the woman should be able to get her haircut anywhere she wants. If this BarberShop was a chain/corporation and this gentlemen is just and employee, 100% she should not be denied a haircut.That being said, if this barber shop is a sole proprietorship/independent/private business, it is in my opinion, he should be allowed to uphold his religious beliefs by choosing which customers he serves (assuming it's his own private business). In the end, it will just hurt his bottom line and if he is okay with that, so be it. While I do agree that under the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, this lady should not be discriminated against based on gender, the Charter also says "as long as it does not infringe on the rights of another." In this case, the Barber has a right in Canada to practice his religious beliefs safely. If I was a betting man, I would lean towards saying this is how the courts would rule.
But that's why we have courts! Haha...that being said, don't know how you "FORCE" someone, IN GENERAL, to cut someone's hair if they don't want to? WHY WOULD YOU EVEN WANT TO GET YOUR HAIRCUT BY SOMEONE WHO DOES NOT WANT TO?!?!?! Haha...might not be the best of haircuts would it?
Thanks Hima! And can you follow up on this in a month and give us the conclusion (if there is one by then)?
- Mr. L
I also totally agree that women should be allowed to get a haircut anywhere. Women should not be forbidden to get a haircut because of their religion. That is discrimination. In Canada, people have equal rights and freedoms despite their race, sex, religion, etc. I think that the barber should allow anyone to get a haircut. If the barber does not do that, he will lose his customers. As a result, his business will lose money.
ReplyDeleteThis is rather an unusual topic for discussion especially for me. I don't know too much about how traditions run in certain nations/religions, but I feel if the girl wants to cut her hair, then by all means let her do it. It's her life and there is no one that can control it. To mix business and religion is hard to do with all the restrictions and loss of profit coming into play. It's all about a compromise that will help get around these obstacles.
ReplyDeleteWell in my opinion this woman made a big deal over nothing. I mean really? You can just drive less than 5 minutes an find another place, it's not like there was something special about that specific place. It is his choice to run his business, and even though it's not giving women and men equal rights in this case, the reason he didn't want to do it was explained to her. It's not like he was like no you're a women leave. It was his religion, just like you said, sometimes it's okay to mix religion and business, and sometimes it's not. Opening a store and only selling to your religion isn't right, but a hair cutting place isn't so bad. You just need to know when to draw the line.
ReplyDeleteSo a Muslim barber can't touch a woman? What do Muslim doctors and dentists do? Do they somehow find a way around their religion in order to practice their trade? Bringing this to the Human Rights Committee seems a little bit excessive, but then the Human Rights Committee itself is a ridiculous and a huge waste of money. Its just a haircut after all, not a life or death situation over possible discrimination.
ReplyDeleteLOL.. I actually laughed reading the beginning of this blog. This is soo interesting yet funny, how did you even find this Hima?!?
ReplyDeleteAnyways, I in my opinion I think that if this man were to run his own business and follow his religion as well he should completely be allowed to. I mean, like it's a free country, who's stopping him?
But at least he should have a sign or something that says men only, that way the woman may have felt less offended and been more open minded about it.
However, if this barber shop is a franchise or chain shop then I think he can be fired for this. I know it's going against his religious beliefs... but then he shouldn't have even been working there in the first place.
Business and religion do indeed clash alot of the times, especially with the religion is Islam, I completely agree with that. But at the most, all we can do it learn to work around it.